Lil Wayne is proof positive that rap superstars now enjoy the kind of unstoppable career momentum that classic rockers have been coasting on for decades. Wayne can go to jail for most of a year, release a horrible rock album with no hits and horrid reviews, and generally abandon the things that he built his fanbase on (great, unexpected punchlines and constant mixtapes) and still move a million in a week just like he did three years ago when the quality of his output was still just beginning to nosedive. All it matters is that he's still on dozens of hit songs ever years, not whether those songs would be just as good if you stripped his vocals off of it (really the only song I can think of in the past 3 years that that doesn't apply to is "Every Girl").

That said, Tha Carter IV isn't as bad as I thought it could be, and it's kind of funny that it's finally engendered a mild backlash against Wayne even from the brainwashed stans and critics who gave a pass to shit like No Ceilings. "How To Hate" is the belated arrival of a Wayne/T-Pain collaboration that's actually worth a damn, and songs like and "Abortion" and "Nightmares Of The Bottom" are kind of tastefully bland but effective, much more tolerable than the brooding 'thoughtful' stuff on Carter III.

Still, even the good stuff on Tha Carter IV isn't quite a dead cat bounce up from his low point a couple years ago, just a comfortable plateau of boring but not quite terrible. The Bruno Mars power ballad on the deluxe version is the kind of "Super Bass"-style deluxe-track-turned-pop-hit I'm afraid of being subjected to over the next year. But we'll see if people still care this much by the time Tha Carter V rolls around, or if Drake and Nicki will be just dutifully pulling their mentor along for the ride the way Kanye does with Jay these days.
« Home | Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »

I don't get this idea that No Ceilings is terrible and only "brainwashed" fans could accept it? It seems like an exaggerated post-superstardom falloff narrative. Not that I can't see why people wouldn't like it as much, it's more punchline > next punchline and not as stream of thought, but his actual rapping is still really good there. I always thought his flow was supposed to be as much a part of the appeal as the lyrics and it's pretty much in top form there. Here there's not a ton of moments where he really goes off in the same way so a general critical backlash makes more sense.
 
not terrible, just mediocre, felt like singling it out since some C4 reviews actual namechecked No Ceilings as part of his peak period which was just mindboggling to me
 
Great review. I completely agree with the review. The Carter 4 is not completely horrible, but it is a disappointment, even worse than the Carter 3. I think he is still adjusting to recording in sober mind state, like Eminem. "Relapse" was a disappointment, but he bounced back with "Recovery". Hopefully, Wayne will also bounce back.

On another note, I remember reading an article you wrote about Wayne in which you described his initial foray into R & B. In this article, you briefly touched upon the progress he made on the Sqad Up mixtapes. You are one of the few writers/critics who are aware of that era in his career, so I was wondering if you could give your opinion on the Sqad Up mixtapes. For some reason, writers/critics tend to ignore that time in Wayne's life.
 
I haven't listened to a lot of the Sqad Up stuff, which I totally should. But yeah, that really is an overlooked period in his career, a lot of people kind of act like there was this totally spontaneous overnight change from Tha Block Is Hot to Tha Carter.
 
Post a Comment