Deep Album Cuts Vol. 231: Carole King





Carole King is one of the 2021 nominees for the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, alongside Jay-ZFoo FightersTina TurnerDevoIron MaidenMary J. BligeLL Cool JTodd RundgrenThe Go-Go'sRage Against The Machine, and New York Dolls, among others. As I noted in Spin a couple years ago, this is long overdue, because King was nominated once in 1989, and then a year later was inducted in the non-performer category alongside her ex-husband and collaborator Gary Goffin for their '60s songwriting work, but then King wasn't nominated for the Hall proper again for 30 years. Hopefully she'll get in this time. 

Carole King deep album cuts (Spotify playlist):

1. I Didn't Have Any Summer Romance
2. Now That Everything's Been Said
3. No Easy Way Down
4. Spaceship Races
5. Tapestry
6. Way Over Yonder
7. Home Again
8. Where You Lead
9. Back To California
10. Music
11. Brighter
12. Feeling Sad Tonight
13. Bitter With The Sweet
14. Haywood
15. A Quiet Place To Live
16. Welfare Symphony
17. A Night This Side Of Dying
18. Wrap Around Joy
19. One Was Johnny
20. So Many Ways
21. Time Alone
22. Disco Tech
23. Passing Of The Days
24. Snow Queen

Track 1 from The Dimension Dolls (1962)
Track 2 from The City's Now That Everything's Been Said (1968)
Tracks 3 and 4 from Writer (1970)
Tracks 5, 6, 7 and 8 from Tapestry (1971)
Tracks 9, 10 and 11 from Music (1971)
Tracks 12 and 13 from Rhymes & Reasons (1972)
Tracks 14, 15 and 16 from Fantasy (1973)
Tracks 17 and 18 from Wrap Around Joy (1974)
Track 19 from Really Rosie (1975)
Track 20 from Thoroughbred (1976)
Track 21 from Simple Things (1977)
Track 22 from Welcome Home (1978)
Track 23 from Touch The Sky (1979)
Track 24 from Pearls: Songs of Goffin and King (1980)

Obviously, Carole King is the ultimate example of a songwriter who transitioned from doing behind-the-scenes work for other artists to becoming a star in her own right. And though she was reticent to perform or tour until after the success of Tapestry, she actually recorded quite a bit as an artist in the decade before that when she and Gary Goffin were enormously successful Brill Building songwriters. She released several solo singles in the '50s and '60s, some on Don Kirshner's Dimension Records label. When Dimension landed a huge hit with "The Loco-Motion," a song King and Goffin wrote for their babysitter Little Eva, the label released The Dimension Dolls, a compilation album featuring several songs apiece by King, Little Eva, and The Cookies (a later lineup of the '50s girl group whose original members had become Ray Charles' Raelettes). The five Carole King songs on that album included her first Top 40 hit as an artist, "It Might As Well Rain Until September," but it would be 9 years before she had another. 

After King divorced Goffin and moved to California, she formed a band with future husband Charles Larkey and Danny Kortchmar, a brilliant guitarist and songwriter perhaps best known for his work with Jackson Browne who'd play a major role in many of King's solo albums. That band, The City, released one album in 1968, and it's a pretty underrated little gem. Two songs from that album later appeared on King's 1980 solo album Pearls. To me it's kind of a mystery why Carole King's first solo album Writer basically did nothing commercially, even though it was released 7 months before Tapestry on the same label, with largely the same sound, and a single featuring James Taylor, whose career had just exploded that year. Writer isn't as good an album as Tapestry, sure, but not by a huge margin, in my opinion. 

Of course, Tapestry is the shining achievement of Carole King's recording career, and justifiably so. Nearly every song on it was a hit, whether for King or for someone else. And even one of the songs that wasn't, "Where You Lead," was re-recorded by King and her daughter Louise Goffin as the theme song of "Gilmore Girls." One of my favorite chapters of David Hepworth's book Never A Dull Moment details how Carole King and Joni Mitchell recorded Tapestry and Blue at the same time in the same building with some of the same personnel and equipment -- two unimpeachable classics, possibly the two most important female singer-songwriter albums of all time, both unique and fairly different from each other.  

Carole King would be an important figure even if she had done nothing of note after Tapestry, and if you didn't know better you might assume she didn't, since that album's place in the canon has grown and grown to the point of eclipsing all her other work. But she was a prolific major star for long after that, and nearly every album she made in the '70s peaked in the top 5 and/or went gold, with a string of over a dozen Top 40 hits. Music, released at Christmastime a few months before Tapestry won big at the Grammys, is estimated to have sold over a million copies in its opening week, a mind-boggling number in the pre-SoundScan era. 

9 out of King's top 10 songs on Spotify are from Tapestry, and the only exception is a surprising one -- "Bitter From The Sweet," an album track from 1972's Rhymes & Reasons. It was the b-side to the album's only hit, "Been To Canaan," but it has over 10 times as many streams as that song, or any other song on the album. I've scoured YouTube comments and other corners of the internet trying to figure out why, and haven't found any notable covers, samples, or film or television placements. It doesn't seem to be nearly as high on King's top songs on Apple Music, so I'm guessing it's a Spotify algorithm aberration, much like the Pavement one detailed in this Stereogum piece. But it's a good song with a funky bassline and a pretty brass arrangement, can't complain if some digital quirk elevated the song. 

1973's Fantasy stands out in Carole King's discography for the way it plays as a 'song cycle' with segues that run from one song into the next -- I included 3 consecutive tracks that work together especially well. Her next album, 1974's Wrap Around Joy, featured two of her biggest post-Tapestry hits, "Jazzman" and "Nightingale." It's also notable in that King co-wrote every song on the album with David Palmer, otherwise best known for his brief tenure in an early lineup of Steely Dan, singing lead on "Dirty Work" and "Brooklyn (Owes The Charmer Under Me)" on their debut album. 

I haven't seen the animated musical based on Maurice Sendak's books that the Really Rosie soundtrack was made for, but the songs on there are pretty charming. I always kind of want singer-songwriters who play piano to make more music with stripped down voice-and-piano arrangements, and 1976's Thoroughbred kind of fits that bill the best in King's catalog, the opener "So Many Ways" is gorgeous. People like to poke fun at the way almost every artist had at least one disco song in the late '70s. But it's kind of fun to hear the author of "The Loco-Motion" and other '60s dance craze hits try her hand at the disco on "Disco Tech" on 1978's Welcome Home, particularly since it was never released as a single. And it felt kind of perversely appropriate to swing straight from that song to possibly King's most country song, "Passing of the Days."  
« Home | Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »
| Next »

Post a Comment