Deep Album Cuts Vol. 401: Billy Joel
Tuesday, April 21, 2026It's been almost a year since Billy Joel canceled his usually robust concert schedule because of his diagnosis of a brain disorder called normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH), but he played two songs with a Billy Joel cover band in January, so I hope he's doing better and still has some good times ahead of him, whether performing or not.
2. Amlifier Fire (with Attila)
3. You Can Make Me Free
4. Stop In Nevada
5. Los Angelenos
6. Summer, Highland Falls
7. Get It Right the First Time
8. Everybody Has A Dream
9. Stiletto
10. Half A Mile Away
11. Sleeping With The Television On
12. Close To The Borderline
13. Laura
14. She's Right On Time
15. Christie Lee
16. Running On Ice
17. Why Should I Worry
18. Storm Front
19. Famous Last Words
20. Suite For Piano (Star-Crossed): Delusion
Track 1 from The Hassles with The Hassles (1970)
Track 2 from Attila with Attila (1970)
Track 1 from The Hassles with The Hassles (1970)
Track 2 from Attila with Attila (1970)
Track 3 from Cold Spring Harbor (1971)
Track 4 from Piano Man (1973)
Track 5 from Streetlife Serenade (1974)
Track 6 from Turnstiles (1976)
Tracks 7 and 8 from The Stranger (1977)
Tracks 9 and 10 from 52nd Street (1978)
Tracks 11 and 12 from Glass Houses (1980)
Tracks 13 and 14 from The Nylon Curtain (1982)
Track 15 from An Innocent Man (1983)
Track 16 from The Bridge (1986)
Track 17 from Oliver & Company (Origional Motion Picture Soundtrack) (1988)
Track 18 from Storm Front (1989)
Track 19 from River of Dreams (1993)
Track 20 from Fantasies & Delusions (2001)
I wrote a Deep Cut Friday column for Spin last year about "You Can Make Me Free," and how it ended up on streaming services today in an edit that's less than half as long as the original album version. There's a YouTube of the full 6-minute song in my article, it's awesome, but I had to settle for the shorter one in this playlist. At the end of the piece I singled out "Stiletto," "Sleeping with the Television On," and "She's Right On Time" as some other essential deep cuts, while also mentioning a variety of Joel album tracks that felt kind of too famous to include in this playlist because of their contemporary popularity on rock radio, streaming services, and/or at Joel concerts: “Captain Jack,” “Scenes From an Italian Restaurant,” “New York State of Mind," “Zanzibar,” and “Miami 2017." There are still some fairly famous songs on the playlist, because I didn't want to whittle away the presence of certain top tier Joel albums, so it was ultimately a gut thing.
Billy Joel recorded three albums with his early bands, two with The Hassles and one with Attila, and there's a handful of tracks from before Joel's solo career on his 2005 box set My Lives. So I grabbed the one Attila song that's on My Lives and a song from the resequenced reissue of The Hassles' debut that's on streaming services. I've long been fascinated by Attila, Joel's psych rock duo with Hassles drummer Jon Small, where he played heavily distorted organ. I really like that album, it would be nice to pick any track of my choosing, but I still enjoyed including "Amplifier Fire."
I recently watched and enjoyed the movie Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice, which opens with Ben Schwartz singing Billy Joel's song from Oliver & Company, "Why Should I Worry." I have a very vague memory of seeing that movie as a child, possibly in the theater when I would've been 6 years old. And I'm pretty sure I loved the song then before I had any idea who Billy Joel was, because the memory just came rushing back when I heard that song again, for the first time in 30-something years. "Running On Ice" is a pretty good Police song, but it is 100% a pastiche of The Police to an almost eerie degree.
It's funny to think that the piano is such a central instrument of western pop music, and yet there are few enough major stars known primarily for singing behind a piano in the last 60 years or so that Elton John and Billy Joel kind of stand apart as the token piano guys. I wish I had seen one of the tours they did together back when they were buddies, it made me sad that they've fallen out to enough of a degree that they didn't appear in each other's recent career-spanning documentaries (Billy Joel: And So It Goes is a great watch, though, see it on HBO if you haven't). I mentioned this in another recent post, but I grew up thinking of them as guys who were both just generally active and successful at the same time. It was only later, upon looking closer, that I realized that Joel's first really huge album The Stranger came out less than a year after Elton John's career started to cool down for the first time with Blue Moves. Maybe there wasn't even room for two token piano guys at a time, just one.
One bone of contention between Billy Joel and Elton John was that Joel stopped writing songs and making albums after River of Dreams and happily transitioned into just performing his back catalog, releasing only a classical album in 2001 (a pretty good new single, "Turn the Lights Back On," came out two years ago, but it appears to be a one-off). Since River of Dreams, Elton John has made 7 solo albums, 4 albums of duets and collaborations, and 5 film soundtracks or stage musical scores. And I've listened to all of that stuff and really like some of it and respect Elton's creative drive and passion for championing new artists. But I don't think he's significantly added to his legacy in that time in ways Joel hasn't, Lion King aside. Plus, not to take anything away from the Elton John/Bernie Taupin partnership, but Billy Joel doesn't have a dedicated lyricist sending him pages of new words to get him started on songs if he's not feeling inspired (Joel says something in the doc about freeing himself from "the tyranny of the rhyme").
And to simply stop recording after a huge album that went platinum 5 times over, continuing to live and perform but never going back to the well trying to extend that time on top, is kinda badass. I don't know if anybody else has really done that in popular music. Some albums sold more than others, but he never really had a flop after The Stranger made him a major star. And River of Dreams isn't his best but it ain't a bad one to go out on. I'm generally not very into covers albums, but it could be cool for Billy Joel to do one, his voice is in much better shape than most stars his age.





