My Top 100 TV Shows of 2024
Saturday, December 21, 20241. "Mr. & Mrs. Smith" (Amazon Prime)
I think the 2005 film Mr. & Mrs. Smith, starring two generational sex symbols who began a tabloid-ready relationship on set, broke some people's brains, because the most common complaint about Donald Glover's "Mr. & Mrs. Smith" was that Glover and co-star Maya Erskine are not as sexy as Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie, as if that's what they were even going for. In fact it's not really the same premise, instead of two married spies, it's two spies who pose as a married couple while on assignment. In any event, it hangs with the best seasons of "Atlanta" and "Community" among Glover's greatest work (I understand he also makes music but I'm pretending I've never heard it), every episode takes a dramatically different approach to the premise and the performances and storytelling are always clever and nuanced.
2. "Evil" (Paramount+)
Every year it feels like there are multiple movies about exorcisms that mimic 1973's The Exorcist as closely as possible, whether or not they're officially connected to the franchise. It's an extremely narrow genre with a single origin point. So "Evil" had a very wide open lane to do something else, and they did just about everything they could in 50 episodes over 5 years about a Catholic priest and a forensic psychologist investigating all manner of possessions, miracles and unexplained phenomena. To call "Evil" a Catholic "X-Files" would actually undersell how relentlessly funny, creepy, and entertaining this show was.
3. "The Franchise" (HBO)
One of my favorite things a television show can do is tell a story from the perspective of someone who isn't typically considered the most important person in their workplace. It's a brilliant idea to make the first assistant director on a tentpole film the main character of "The Franchise," to make Hamish Patel the guy who has to run around soothing the egos of the pretentious director, the deeply insecure lead actor, and the overqualified actor playing the villain. The show also allows for hilarious but sometimes very empathetic depictions of all sorts of below-the-line people on the set, from the sleep-deprived visual effects guy to the extras. My favorite cast of 2024, including Richard E. Grant, Aya Cash, Billy Magnussen, and Darren Goldstein from "The Affair" revealing himself as a comedic genius.
4. "Presumed Innocent" (Apple TV+)
Apple TV+ does a lot of dark, intense courtroom dramas and murder mysteries, and "Presumed Innocent" is by far the most gripping of them. I hadn't read the novel or seen the previous film adaptation with Harrison Ford (both of which apparently have different endings), but I was just on the edge of my seat the entire time and genuinely surprised by the final episode. Career best performances by Jake Gyllenhaal and Ruth Negga, the best thing from David E. Kelley 2.0's prestige TV run since "Big Little Lies."
5. "Girls5Eva" (Netflix)
Every network and streamer cancels more shows than it renews, but Netflix wound up with a reputation as the bad guy that cancels everything, partly earned but partly because they simply make more shows than everyone else by several orders of magnitude. So I will give Netflix some credit for picking up "Girls5Eva" for a third season after Peacock failed to renew it, giving me another season of Renee Elise Goldsberry and Paula Pell being two of the funniest women on television. Yes, "Girls5Eva" just got canceled for the second time, by Netflix this time, but they didn't have to pick it up in the first place, and getting 3 seasons instead of 2 is really the point where I usually start to feel like a show got a fair shot, so I'm not gonna hold this one against Netflix.
6. "We Are Lady Parts" (Peacock)
"We Are Lady Parts" is a slightly more empathetic look at a more DIY kind of girl group than "Girls5Eva," but it's often hilarious in its own right, quite likely the first good sitcom about a punk band. Sarah Kameela Impey is the standout that I'll be looking out for in other projects in the years ahead, in 2024 she was also the only good thing about an episode of the otherwise mediocre "Dinner with the Parents."
7. "Expats" (Amazon Prime)
In 2017, Nicole Kidman pledged to do a project with a woman director every 18 months, and she's more than exceeded that goal with 15 films or series since then. My favorite of those projects is "Expats" from The Farewell director Lulu Wang, an exquisitely lensed and emotionally complex tale of American families living in Hong Kong. Kidman's character isn't even really the most important role or most impressive performance in the series, which I would say is Ji-young Yoo, but my hat's off to Kidman for helping this get made.
8. "What We Do In The Shadows" (Hulu)
In this fragile streaming era, a show as good and as ridiculous as "What We Do In The Shadows" getting six seasons is a miracle, especially because the quality never dipped. This year they ended their absurd vampire story with an even more absurd arc with a Frankenstein storyline and a ghost. I can't wait to see what Matt Berry, Kayvan Novak and Natasia Demetriou do next.
9. "Manhunt" (Apple TV+)
Steven Spielberg didn't depict the president's assassination in Lincoln, figuring, probably correctly, that it would've overwhelmed the rest of the story. That left a lane open for a great miniseries about the assassination and aftermath, and "Manhunt" did a fantastic job with it. I've spent probably a couple hundred hours in Ford's Theatre, often right under the place Lincoln was killed, and I've left the building out the same alley where John Wilkes Booth escaped, so it was fascinating seeing the whole tragedy recreated on location, but obviously there's a lot more to the show, which centers on the 12 days Booth was on the run.
10. "Abbott Elementary" (ABC)
"Abbott Elementary" being consistently excellent is no longer news. But I'm glad they're still going and showing us how it's done, gradually expanding the cast of recurring players, subtly evolving the main characters and their relationships, and maybe relying on celebrity cameos a little less than they did after that initial burst of awards and acclaim.
11. "So Help Me Todd" (CBS)
I try to advocate for the old Big Four broadcast networks and show them praise when they get things right instead of just ignoring them entirely outside of "Abbott" like many do. They don't make it easy on me, though, canceling a great show like "So Help Me Todd" starring Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin after only two seasons. It even ended with a cliffhanger, goddammit!
12. "Bodkin" (Netflix)
The true crime podcast industrial complex is one of my least favorite aspects of popular culture these days. So I'm glad it's become a punching bag for TV comedy, between "Only Murders in the Building," "Based On a True Story," and this show starring Will Forte as the fish-out-of-water American podcaster visiting an Irish town full of secrets.
13. "Interior Chinatown" (Hulu)
"Interior Chinatown" sends up an older and more firmly entrenched genre, the crime procedural, with Jimmy O. Yang basically playing a day player from a cold open of a "Law & Order"-type show who gets involved in the story and becomes the star of his own show. Great concept, great execution.
14. "Lady in the Lake" (Apple TV+)
It's been a while since Barry Levinson made a period piece about the Baltimore of his youth. So I enjoyed seeing director Almar Har-el's vision of '60s Baltimore, complete with Natalie Portman as a reporter for a fictionalized Baltimore Sun (the 'Baltimore Star'), she has a good eye for filming Baltimore for an out-of-towner. It even brought Wood "Avon Barksdale" Harris back to the city!
15. "I'm A Virgo" (Amazon Prime)
Boots Riley has really made a remarkable pivot from music to film and television. For my money this is an even more accomplished step into poignantly absurdist storytelling than Sorry to Bother You, I hope he keeps getting opportunities to get behind a camera.
16. "Hacks" (Max)
I've seen people criticize the jokes that the characters on "Hacks" write, as if the show isn't called "Hacks." The character-driven and conflict-driven laughs on the show hit the hardest anyway, but I'm a sucker for some of those hackier punchlines anyway, it's probably the best show about how the comedy sausage is made since "30 Rock," even if it approaches it in a very different way.
17. "Time Bandits" (Apple TV+)
Lisa Kudrow has consistently done the most good work of any member of the "Friends" cast, and this year she ran up the score with starring roles in both the Netflix dark comedy "No Good Deed" and the Apple TV+ adaptation of the 1981 film Time Bandits. I was probably too young the first time I saw the original Time Bandits and it left a huge footprint on my brain, and I enjoyed what the "What We Do In The Shadows" creative team did with the reboot. Kal-El Tuck is so incredibly funny and on point as a child actor, that kid's going places.
18. "Fallout" (Amazon Prime)
Ella Purnell probably edges out Kudrow with the most impressive pair of lead performances in two different shows in 2024, "Fallout" and "Sweetpea." I've never played the Fallout video game, but I really enjoyed how they transferred that world to a story populated with a ghoulish Walton Goggins and Matt Berry-voiced robots.
19. "The Decameron" (Netflix)
The cancellation of the last few years that I'm most bitter about is Kathleen Jordan's "Teenage Bounty Hunters," which only lasted one season. So at least Jordan's latest Netflix project was designed as a miniseries from the get-to so I never got my hopes up. And I loved how she turned 14th century Italian literature into a madcap ensemble sitcom with Tony Hale and Zosia Mamet.
20. "Hot Ones" (YouTube)
About a week ago, Buzzfeed sold the company that produces "Hot Ones" for $82.5 million to a consortium of investors that includes the show's host Sean Evans. To some, this was a funny or depressing story about the value of silly chicken wing-themed YouTube content, but I thought it was a rare feelgood story in this hellish media landscape. Evans is one of the best interviewers on television of any kind these days, and he totally deserves to own a piece of the silly phenomenon he built into what is frequently the most entertaining and even most intellectually stimulating stop on a celebrity's promotional junket.
21. "Conan O'Brien Must Go" (Max)
Conan O'Brien has been a comedy genius for decades, and this year people finally treated him like one after the debut of his hilarious travel series and his even funnier "Hot Ones" appearance. And now he's going to host the fucking Oscars in March! I'm so excited for that. The Conanaissance is here.
22. "The Diplomat" (Netflix)
Nostalgia for "The West Wing" took another fatal hit this year when Aaron Sorkin published a moronic op-ed suggesting that the Democratic party run Mitt Romney as its presidential nominee. But a "West Wing" writer and producer, Debora Cahn, created the kind of smart, snappy political drama that Sorkin lost the ability to make a long time ago, and they even added Allison Janney for the second season!
23. "Feud: Capote Vs The Swans" (FX)
I can't tell if Ryan Murphy was interrogating his own catty fascination with the controversies of the rich and glamorous in the harsh way he depicts Truman Capote in the second season of "Feud" or if he only accidentally made a show about himself. In either event, it's one of the only worthwhile things he's made in years, with some great meta casting of several generations of Hollywood it girls including Demi Moore, Molly Ringwald, Chloe Sevigny, and the unexpected standout, Calista Flockhart.
24. "English Teacher" (FX)
Enrico Colantoni is so good as the beleaguered principal on "English Teacher," his best role since "Veronica Mars." Sean Patton is hilarious too, I'd never seen him in anything before. A really fucked up story about other stars of this show was just published a few days ago, so that's all I'm gonna say right now. Yikes!
25. "Agatha All Along" (Disney+)
"WandaVision" set up a Kathryn Hahn spinoff series so brilliantly in early 2021 that my main criticism is that they didn't have one in the works right from the bat, it would've hit better if it didn't take three and a half years to show up. Jac Schaeffer is definitely one of the only people working in the MCU right now who has a real vision, though. Keep her busy, please.
26. "Three Women" (Showtime)
27. "Shrinking" (Apple TV+)
28. "La Maquina" (Hulu)
29. "Sweetpea" (Starz)
30. "A Man On The Inside" (Netflix)
31. "Only Murders In The Building" (Hulu)
32. "Bob's Burgers" (Fox)
33. "Shoresy" (Hulu)
34. "Bad Sisters" (Apple TV+)
35. "Say Nothing" (Hulu)
36. "Fantasmas" (HBO)
37. "Shogun" (FX)
38. "Bad Monkey" (Apple TV+)
39. "Somebody Somewhere" (HBO)
40. "No Good Deed" (Netflix)
41. "The Sex Lives of College Girls" (Max)
42. "St. Denis Medical" (NBC)
43. "The Old Man" (FX)
44. "Based On A True Story" (Peacock)
45. "The Acolyte" (Disney+)
46. "Last Week Tonight" (HBO)
47. "The Bear" (Hulu)
48. "Mary & George" (Starz)
49. "How To Die Alone" (Hulu)
50. "The Tragically Hip: No Dress Rehearsal" (Amazon Prime)
51. "A Good Girl's Guide To Murder" (Netflix)
52. "Death And Other Details" (Hulu)
53. "One Day" (Netflix)
54. "For All Mankind" (Apple TV+)
55. "Animal Control" (Fox)
56. "The Brothers Sun" (Netflix)
57. "The Sympathizer" (HBO)
58. "UnPrisoned" (Hulu)
59. "A Man In Full" (Netflix)
60. "Renegade Nell" (Disney+)
61. "My Lady Jane" (Amazon Prime)
62. "Bridgerton" (Netflix)
63. "The Veil" (Hulu)
64. "Disclaimer" (Apple TV+)
65. "The Madness" (Netflix)
66. "Joan" (The CW)
67. "Nobody Wants This" (Netflix)
68. "The Boys" (Amazon Prime)
69. "Saturday Night Live" (NBC)
70. "Before" (Apple TV+)
71. "Silo" (Apple TV+)
72. "Dune: Prophecy" (HBO)
73. "The Legend of Vox Machina" (Amazon Prime)
74. "Palm Royale" (Apple TV+)
75. "The Regime" (HBO)
76. "Not Dead Yet" (ABC)
77. "The Girls On The Bus" (Max)
78. "Invincible" (Amazon Prime)
79. "The Big Door Prize" (Apple TV+)
80. "Under The Bridge" (Hulu)
81. "Sunny" (Apple TV+)
82. "STAX: Soulsville U.S.A." (HBO)
83. "Futurama" (Hulu)
84. "Geek Girl" (Netflix)
85. "Dark Matter" (Apple TV+)
86. "Jerrod Carmichael Reality Show" (HBO)
87. "Trying" (Apple TV+)
88. "Life & Beth" (Hulu)
89. "Poppa's House" (CBS)
90. "Fight Night: The Million Dollar Heist" (Peacock)
91. "The New Look" (Apple TV+)
92. "Mr. Throwback" (Peacock)
93. "The Penguin" (HBO)
94. "The Completely Made-Up Adventures of Dick Turpin" (Apple TV+)
95. "The Vince Staples Show" (Netflix)
96. "Loot" (Apple TV+)
97. "Will Trent" (ABC)
98. "The Daily Show" (Comedy Central)
99. "Monsieur Spade" (AMC)
100. "Reacher" (Amazon Prime)